
Broadway Avenue in Urbana, that is. Located in the little building that housed Tod & John's bar for 30 years, the Black Dog opened for business this week. Doesn't look like much from the outside, but inside, glowy burnt-orange walls and lots of wood make for a warm, inviting place to enjoy the food that is now the main attraction at the tavern.

And what food! Owners Mike Cochran and Pedro Heller, of Esquire Lounge and Philo Tap fame, have invested in an enormous wood-fired smoker and wood-fired grill and rotisserie, and they're smoking beef brisket, pork shoulder, ribs, chicken, and more 24 hours a day for your eating pleasure (you'll smell the wonderful aroma as you approach the door). Take a look at this puppy:

The bottom portion holds the wood that creates the smoke, and convection in the top portion circulates the smoke so that the meat on the many racks cooks evenly. Mike told this reporter that it takes about 10 hours to smoke a brisket.

And in the closet-sized kitchen just off the bar area sits a wood-fired grill and rotisserie. Yowza. This is doing BBQ right!
When we visited, we started with the Santa Fe Smoked Chicken Soup ($2.50 cup/$4.00 bowl). Man, was it ever good. Thick, and piping hot, the made-from-scratch soup was filled with deliciously smoky shredded chicken, white beans, and veggies. A real stand out. And you could definitely make a meal out of a bowl of this stuff.

Next, we sampled a BBQ brisket sandwich (topped with a bit of red-cabbage slaw and homemade barbecue sauce, in a nod to the way they do BBQ sandwiches in North Carolina) for me and the Black Dog Burger for Keith. You have your choice of potato salad, pit beans, French fries, or sweet potato fries on the side (the non-BBQ sandwiches also come with a side of your choice).

The brisket was melt-in-your-mouth tender with a fabulous flavor and some charred bits. The bun was slightly toasted. It was heavenly (although the meat could have been a titch warmer). I had sweet potato fries with my sandwich, and those, sadly, were not very good—limp and soggy. However, it was only the tavern's second day in business, and they were absolutely slammed at lunch time, so I don't fault them for the soggy sweet potatoes. I think I just got a bad batch, because we heard other patrons raving about them.

Keith's regular (hand-cut) French fries, on the other hand, were perfectly cooked—crispy and hot. His burger was very tasty, too. The onion on it had been smoked, and the dusky flavor really came through. That, combined with the pepper Jack cheese and the hot/sweet BBQ sauce, made for some great eatin'. Our only quibble was that the burger was a tad overcooked and so not as juicy as we would have liked. But that was a small quibble.

If a sandwich isn't enough for you, you can order a platter of BBQ. Platters come with two sides (see above; after 5 p.m. a smoked potato and smoked sweet potato are also available, as are spare ribs). Don't want beef or pork? Then check out the BBQ catfish or chicken.
Sandwiches and platters are served just the way I've seen it done at roadside BBQ joints in the south: on a personal-sized tray covered with paper. I loved that little touch. I also loved the old-timey, diner-type glasses that the home-brewed iced tea came in.

This kind of attention to detail really enhances the dining experience; the care that obviously went into the planning of the place, along with the very reasonable prices (we had two beverages, two cups of soup, and two sandwich plates, and our bill was $20), sends a message that the owners aim to create a truly special atmosphere that's affordable to the greatest number of people possible. That said, if you're a vegetarian—well, this really isn't your place. You can get a grilled cheese, fries, and a salad, and that's about it.

In talking with Mike, I discovered that he's going to be working with Stan of
Triple S Farm (the local farm where Keith and I get our meat). On maybe a once-a-week basis, the Black Dog will offer smoked meats from Triple S Farm as specials. I was thrilled to learn of the owners' interest in supporting a local producer. And speaking of small producers, at the Black Dog they'll also offer ales from breweries in Illinois, Wisconsin, and Michigan.

Before I wind this up, I must share one last item. This graphic on the back wall shows you where the restrooms are located (name of the place is Black
Dog, get it?).

And on the restroom doors, "Oscar" invites you into the men's room, while "Lola" signals the women's.
Be forewarned that at lunchtime—that is, the 12:00 to 1:00 hour, the place will probably be packed (there were people waiting for tables/seats at the bar to open up during that hour when we were there). If you can manage it, I recommend going early, say 11:00 to 11:30, or late, 12:45 to 1:00 p.m. or thereafter.
Take yourself over to the Black Dog and get you some barbecue, y'all. This pint-sized smokehouse is the real deal, and I highly recommend it. Thanks to Mike and Pedro for all their efforts; I wish them many years of success.
UPDATE 2/27/09: We went in for lunch on Saturday the 21st before picking up our meat from Stan in the Lincoln Square parking lot. We found that the menu had changed a bit, so I wanted to fill you in.
There are several new additions: smoked chicken wings (6 wings with celery and smoked blue cheese dip, to die for, $4.95), a smoked chorizo sausage sandwich (yum), and a smoked chicken breast sandwich. Look for other new menu items in the coming weeks as well.
Another thing that has changed is that the BD chef extraordinaire will be whipping up a different soup daily; the Santa Fe smoked chicken soup we had on our first visit will certainly be in the rotation, though. On my visit today (Feb. 23), I ordered the soup du jour, which was a pork stew with potatoes, green chilis, and corn. It was as tastebud-alteringly good as last week's chicken soup.
I had reported in an earlier update that the BD no longer had grilled cheese on the menu, but IT'S BACK! A friend ordered it last night and reported that it was yummy.
One final food note: Don't miss the pit beans (baked beans). Great Northerns in a smoky "gravy" with pieces of pork . . . . I'll let you imagine the rest. Now, if they could just get rid of the styrofoam cups they serve some of the sides in . . . I imagine that will come in time.
The Black Dog Smoke and Ale House201 North Broadway Avenue
Urbana, IL
217-344-9334
Open Monday through Saturday at 11 a.m. Closed on Sundays.
Labels: bars and clubs