Quest for the Best Cuban Sandwich: Pekara Bakery
- Aroma Cafe,
- the Black Dog,
- Escobar's, and
- Radio Maria.
The bread was definitely the best thing about the Pekara Cuban sandwich—it was really wonderful. Nothing like the traditional bread used for a Cuban, but wonderful nevertheless. The Provolone cheese was nice and melty, but why do they use Provolone instead of Swiss? The ham was tasty, and it didn't overpower the other fillings. The pork, though, was hard to distinguish from the ham. It was called "Cuban pork" in the menu description, but I couldn't discern any flavors that would warrant the name. The sandwich was lacking in the pickle department, too. There were some pieces of chopped dill pickle on top of the meats, and that didn't get the job done. I want nice, thick slices of pickle on my Cuban. Condiment-wise, there were both mustard and mayo. Purists might recoil at the mention of mayo, but I love the stuff so I didn't mind it at all. As long as I can see and taste yellow mustard, I'm happy.
At $7.76, coming to a total of $8-something with tax, the price of the Pekara Cuban is steep. There's not a lot of meat on it, and they make their own bread, so I don't see why the price should be so high (the sandwich is served with a small bag of chips and a pickle spear).
Compared to, say, the Black Dog Cuban, which is piled with luscious, house-smoked meats, boasts long, thick slices of pickle, comes with your choice of homemade side, and costs $6.95? Well—the Black Dog wins that round, even though their specimen has very little to do with a traditional Cuban sandwich. I don't love their addition of grilled onions or the chipotle mayo they dress the sandwich with instead of French's mustard. But hey, those are their special twists, and I can add my own mustard, as it's right there on the bar. Traditional or not, it's a fabulous sandwich.
Next, let's put up the Aroma Cafe Cuban as a challenger ($6.95, served with your choice of small salad, fresh fruit cup, or chips and salsa). Of the two Cubans, I'd say Pekara's edges out the Aroma version, even with its high price tag. The Aroma Cuban, while very authentic in ingredients (ham, pork, Swiss cheese, pickles, yellow mustard) and preparation, can be tough to eat owing to bread that's so crunchy it's hard to bite into. The hardness comes, I think, from an overlong stay in the sandwich press.
The Escobar's version of the sandwich is splendid, but at $9 (which gets you a small salad of baby greens and also homemade sweet potato fries with homemade catsup), and in that environment, this is your fancy-dress, not your everyday, Cuban sandwich.
And if we're talking about the Radio Maria Cuban ($7, with choice of homemade side), it's sort of the same situation as Escobar's: High-end restaurant, full table service, not your bare-bones, workhorse sandwich. It's fancy! However, look at the great price on the RM sandwich, which is huge and which comes with your choice of interesting, homemade side dishes.
The Aroma Cafe version is the most authentic of all these Cuban sandwiches. None of the others is finished off in a sandwich press, and the Cuban isn't meant to be a sandwich on steroids but a workin' man's pick-it-up-and-go staple.
So—the choice is yours. Do you like a Cuban sandwich? If so, which is your favorite around town? (And, if you know of a restaurant that makes a Cuban other than those I've mentioned, please let me know in the comments.)
Labels: restaurants








